Socialism is one type of government where the emphasis is on economic equality among citizens. In a socialist country like Norway, for instance, the state government plays an important role in establishing and maintaining economic equality through progressive taxation policies that limit inequality between the wealthiest and the poorest members of the society.
Over the next couple of weeks we are going to talk about totalitarianism. We'll talk about the origins of the word, the conditions out of which totalitarians forms of government emerge, its goals and features, the relationship between the government and the citizen, and a number of other interesting topics related to this type of political arrangement.
Like socialism, the state government plays an important role in a totalitarian political arrangement. But, in a totalitarian system, the power and presence of the state is intensified well beyond that of a well functioning socialist democracy like Norway. In a totalitarians system the state and its charismatic leadership become omnipresent features of peoples' everyday lives. Indeed, in the most extreme cases, the aspects of your life that you usually call "private" practically disappear.
As with our discussion of socialism, one of my class goals is to offer thought provoking comparisons between the system that we currently live in and these other forms of government that we're talking about in class. Read the list of characteristics associated with populations governed by a totalitarian regime and think about our own system of government.
Populations living under totalitarian rule are usually...
1. Party Minded -- the individual person sees their selves as an instrument of the political party.
2. Patriotic -- there is an intense love, affection, and loyalty for one's country, historical myths, and political leadership.
3. Collectivist -- the individual's own private prerogatives, goals, aspirations, enjoyments are downplayed, while the public goals of the collective are the most important.
4. Vigilant -- the enemy is seen as dangerous, everywhere, and camouflaged. So, there is a more or less permanent sense of readiness to uncover the activities of the public enemy of the people, the state, and its leadership.
5. Hate filled -- the enemy of the people, the state, and its leadership are the object of this hate, which is matched by a strong sense of patriotic love of the one's country.
6. Love work and political activism -- contemplation and reflection is shunned, while positive political action and work that benefits the community is celebrated.
7. Disciplined -- people easily obey figures of authority and curb their own private desires for the betterment of the collective.
8. Modest and puritan -- there is an emphasis on self sacrifice, self denial, self discipline and, in general, taming individual desires and wants.
What do you think?
Do any of these eight features associated with totalitarian governments resemble aspects of life in our political system? Which ones? Can you describe how they resemble aspects of our political system?
Or, alternatively, do none of these eight features of a totalitarian system resemble our own system of government? Is our system and a totalitarian system opposites with nothing in common? What do you think are the key differences between our system and a totalitarian system?
I think we are similar in some ways..Such as patriotic. We are proud to be Americans but the negative aspect between the two is that we do not have a major love for our political leadership. I would have to call these halfsies. We are opposite in most of these totally because I do not think we as view our political party as the most important aspect of our day. We don't always agree with what the politicians say or try to pursuade us to agree with. My privacy is important to me and my family. I would not share it with others. I feel this just allows people to be sneaky in order to get around the totalitarian governments ears. However we do listen to authority that holds a consequence if we disobey, which is another similarity. Having so many differences between our government and a totalitarian ruler, I would totally fail if I lived within their reign.
ReplyDeletewe are similar in some ways, and different in others. For instance. We are similar in that we are very patriotic. After September 11th people often raised the american flag to heighten the hopes of the american citizens. We are very vigilant - we're always scared of an unknown enemy lurking around the corner. thats way we all lock our house and car doors and rely on public defense and so forth. We are very hate filled. As discussed in class today we constantly show the face of terrorists on tv, not only to make their faces known, but to inspire rage toward them for how they have wronged us. To a certain extent we are disciplined, but it varies so much from person to person that it is hard to pin it all in one generalization. Most people tend to follow the laws, at the least the minor ones, to avoid the consequences. Yet there are still those who have no regard to discipline at all. In a way we are party minded because we are an active part of political system when we do such things as vote - yet it doesn't correlate 100% because there are two sides of the said "party". However I would not say that we are in any way collectivists, Lovers work and political activism, or Modest and puritan because we are far too selfish to preform such deeds.
ReplyDeleteYasmin Modica
Poli Sci 100.04
I agree with Christina that is a half and half split. We are patriotic, vigilant, hate filled and party minded. But we lack collectivism, love work and political activism, dicipline, and modest and puritan. We see ourselves as Americans and hate the images of osoma bin laden whenever we see it. We are always weary that another attack could happen and even have a warning system set up just for the purpose to warn us. I'll even go as far to say that we see ourselves as an instrument of the political party because like you mentioned in class we may disagree with the government but we don't do much about it besides say "well they only way to make a change is to vote in the next election". We feel like pawn on the governments chess board. Still there is disagreement with the government and are free to reflect on it's short fallings. We also don't follow the law easily as exhibited by the number of people dead from shootings and drug overdoses every year. And over all we are working towards our own ends and pushing others out of our minds. So our government may have a bit in common with totalitarian government but we aren't hiding in a corner just to write in a journal just yet.
ReplyDeleteWe are similar in a few ways such as the two above said, we are very patriotic. We are all proud to be Americans. We stand up and honor our country with our anthem and much more. Also, I agree that we are vigilant, todays world is scary so we constantly lock our doors and look out for ourselves and hope there some type of defense around such as the police.. I think we are so vigilant today because of what happened of September 11th and people, even our own people are threats to our very own lives as well.
ReplyDeleteStephanie Hudlow
psci 100.05
We barely, if any, resemble a totalitarian government system. Yes, Americans can be patriotic, and they can be vigilant towards our enemies and be prepared to stand up for our country. But, the main thought we have to be aware of is that in a totalitarian government they do not know anything else, their choice is gone because they aren’t raised or brought up with any other way of thinking like we are. Freedom is the difference, freedom is the factor that separates us from them, and freedom is what makes up America’s differences. America is known as a melting pot of dissimilarities, and known for the choices we have. We aren’t sheltered or made into spitting images of each other to keep us in order or at bay from questioning the government’s decisions. The people of the United States question our government and their choices constantly and for that we do have continuous change, and are free to have thoughts that do not necessarily parallel directly to our leadership’s decisions and actions.
ReplyDeleteLaura Elkins PSCI 100.4
Considering the diversity of interest American people have in our government, perception of government can alter one's views upon it. For instance, some Americans are patriotic for a variety of reasons. One American can be called patriotic for completely opposing reasons as another American that is called patriotic. Just as on the other hand, some Americans are Party-Minded. Some of these party-minded Americans associate much of their lives with the particular political party they think is the best way for this country. There are also extremes to this mindset towards parties, just as there are extremists for every type of passion. Certain Americans are convinced that the "enemy" is the source of much evil, and a vigilant reaction sometimes is conditioned into the brain workings of American minds. This is not true for every American, but much hate has been a result of the "us vs. them" mindset. This is what happens when love for one's country becomes very strong and packed full of pride. There are various ways as to how this can happen, but moving on, Americans are also taught from when they are small children to be disciplined citizens. Overall, the words listed above in the post can be applied to many different forms of governments in many countries. The extremes manifestations of the words are what makes certain forms of governments stand out and cause counteractive reactions in humans.
ReplyDeleteOf these eight features associated with totalitarian government, seventy-five percent of them are present in the United States. Patriotism-our country is extremely patriotic; flags can be seen flying at schools, banks, sometimes even at parks and churches. Before sports events, the National Anthem is sung, even though some of those who sing it forget the words. Collectivist-the governments is always speaking about doing something for the people as a whole. Security and the economy are two of the most talked about topics. Vigilant-as said in class, the "face of evil" is currently Osama bin Laden; he is perhaps the most hated and disgusted person. Hate filled-while Americans may not seem to be filled with hate, they do harbor feelings of disgust towards anything and anyone that opposes the United States and what it stands for. Love work and political activism-Americans, from birth, are taught to be successful and to love work. We are to be happy with the job that we have because some are do not have the ability to get a job. We are also urged to vote and to bring a positive change to the country as a whole. Disciplined-as much as we hate when "the man" puts us down, we are taught to obey forms of hierarchy whether it be the police, judges, senators, teachers, parents, etc. We are taught to respect and obey all laws whether we approve of them as individuals or not.
ReplyDeleteZachary Roach
PSCI 100.4
Of the eight different concepts associated with totalitarianism, I would say that almost all of them apply to the United States in some shape or form. Although I would say that only three of these concepts truly effect the United States in any sort of profound, everyday life way. There is an undeniable sense of patriotism in the United States which would fall under the patriotic concept of totalitarianism. Although patriotism in this country is very different than a totalitarian system. In the U.S. people are patriotic towards symbols of the country, we are not nessisarally showing patriotism towards the government power. In a totalitarian system, patriotism is not shown by putting your hand over your heart and saying the pledge of allegiance, it is obeying the government and never questioning its authority. Also the U.S. is definitely collectivist because when 9/11 happened, most everyone put aside their differences and worked together to get justice for those fellow Americans who were killed. A totalitarian version of collectivism, however, creates a rally effect around the government, not for a specific cause, but just to gather as a loyal force to the totalitarian system. Finally the U.S. as well as totalitarian systems really focus on a vigilant mind set. The U.S. is constantly monitoring borders, wire tapping, and creating barriers to keep the enemy at bay. Totalitarian systems observe everyone at every moment to prevent an uprising of the enemy at any time. So while the U.S. capitalist system and a totalitarian system believe in many of the same concepts, they carry them out in significantly different manors.
ReplyDeleteSarah Jeffries, PSCI 100.05
The aspects of totalitarianism resemble our government in many ways such as the collectivism of the population, the patriotism of the nation, hate filled as far as those who oppose our government(enemies of the state). The totalitarian government is in some ways great they focus on the collective good, things such as housing are given. The downside of this form of government is a freedom of individuality. i believe this causes harm to the general public, because they cannot express them selves. Take the government of North Korea for example, they're raised to believe that their leader is a GOD and anything said or done against him is seen as an attack on the state. In our country you can disgrace the president himself and nothing will be done, because were protected by our freedom of expression.
ReplyDeleteCordova, Jacob PSCI 100:05
Hannah Hime PSCI 100.04
ReplyDeleteI think our government is nothing of a totalitarian government. Our patriotism basically stops after our greatfulness for our freedoms and people who fight for us. The patriotism that is described above is more fake. It deals with the historical myths people believe in for themselves to "think" their country is great. Also the love of government officials is not always present. Americans often complain about the government officials, but our patriotism is being greatful that we have a more fair form of government. I think the US can admit thier wrongs rather than change it with historical myths or try to make something legit with a myth.
I think that our government is not like a totalitarian government in most way but in some ways it is. I feel as though there are more similarities than people would wish to acknowledge. Patriotism is obviously shared between the two systems. While they differ in the degree of their intensity I think the principle behind it is the same. I think that "we" are also fairly party minded. Some of us more than others, but many people strongly identify as part of a specific party. I think that the people in this country are also fairly disciplined. There is obviously a lot of crime in this country but I think that there is much more discipline in the people that choose to obey the laws, even the ones that seem useless.
ReplyDeleteIn some ways, the American government does seem to resemble a totalitarian system, yet I don't believe the American government has the same intentions as a totalitarian system. Our government does promote patriotism and hate for the enemy, but those two qualities make a country a true country. If the people of a America didn't have love for their country and hate for the enemy, then I feel that the country wouldn't be very stable. Another way to make our country stable is the idea of discipline, which is one of the eight features of a totalitarian system. Discipline is also a need though because we don't want to feel unsafe within our own community. Even though there are some ways that the American government does represent a totalitarian system, we still aren't one because we believe in individualism. Our government allows each individual to pursue their own aspirations and dreams without the force of a higher authority, such as the president or congress. The American government only has the intention to keep the people of their country happy and safe, not because they want to corrupt them.
ReplyDeleteKelly Sweeney
PSCI 100.05
I would say that our government does have some of these characteristics. Patriotism is one that stands out for me, as we refer to ourselves as a collective "we". Of the characteristics, I think that is the only one that is really poignant in our culture. I think the key differences between our political system and totalitarianism is our aims. Our government wants to control the population to a point, yes, but they do not try to force us to completely submit to their will, nor do they deny us a certain level of privacy, which is denied in totalitarian systems.
ReplyDeleteRebecca Herbert, 100.05
Brandi Parsons PSCI 100.04 In our government, I would say the only aspects of a totalitarianism system that we display is patriotism and being hate filled. There are certain days of the year in which people celebrate their independence and freedom whereas other places lack this ability. I would say some portions of our economy is hate filled because as others said we are taught to display hate towards our enemies. Of the eight categories of a totalitarian system I believe those are the only two that are displayed in our government.
ReplyDeleteWe are a pretty large country; there is no doubt in my mind that somewhere in the United States all 8 of the features you describe comes into play. We all know we are pretty well the epitome of patriotic, that’s something that we seem to have a pretty good handle on, another thing I would suggest we have a handle on is being hate filled, in general, and anything that threatens the U.S. Soil. Vigilant, most definitely, besides we spend trillions of dollars to keep ourselves safe just in case. Party minded, collectivist, love work and political activism, I think are not for everyone, I’m sure there are some extremist out there that go to the lengths as those but I don’t think it’s a consensus for all people. Not everyone toys with politics. Disciplined and modest and puritan I would consider a case by case basis. I do agree that we are far too greedy to be anything close to modest in our society. We have to take everything to the hilt. Even though we have a lot of similarities I believe that we are nothing like a totalitarian rule.
ReplyDeleteMarChell DeShong 100.04
I would have to agree with the majority here and say that we do have some similarities, but we are polar opposites on other things. We are very patriotic as a whole and proud to be in America. When we see an American flag, it is a symbol of hope and our Country as a whole. However, as Christina said, we still don't follow the Government completely. Most citizens just view it as a necessary evil. It is there to protect us and set boundaries, but we don't like it messing with our private lives. While we are proud to be American, we are also proud to be an individual. We don't want the government telling us exactly how to run our lives.
ReplyDeleteKatherine Martin PSCI 100.04
ReplyDeleteI think that every country teaches their people to have such great pride in their country that they are willing to do just about anything for their country when things get a bit out of control. When we talk about the control over the people in the land of a totalitarian government and the fact that from the time they are born they have been taught to think a certain way, and act a certain way. In American we have our own rituals that we have been taught from a very early age as well. When you hear the national anthem you place your hand over your heart and stand and face a flag. At certain events we say the pledge of allegiance to the flag in which again you place your hand over your heart and repeat the exact words you have been taught. There are precise ceremonies for how to burn a flag, and in order to have a flag hanging there are guidelines in which we are suppose to follow. I do not believe this makes us a totalitarian society but it does show that we do have things in which are placed before us that we follow as American citizens.
ReplyDeleteKaren Martin PSCI 100.04
Our government for the most part is completely different from that of a totalitarian government. One similarity is present on the list,Pride and patriotism, these are traits we are taught to respect at a very young age. We, as Americans, take pride in our flag and respectfully acknowledge the national anthem, but as for the rest of the characteristics I do not believe those are evident in our current government. Americans have the ability to be their own person; the government does not strip away our personality or individuality. People are taught to value themselves and reach for success in all things attempted. Our President is not viewed with eyes filled with hate nor is he portrayed as the enemy. Individuals put their trust in the government and do not fear outside attacks on a daily basis. Thankfully, our government shares very few characteristics with the totalitarian way of governing.
ReplyDeleteI have to agree with most of the class because the symbloic meaning of our flag is the we are proud to be an American like it says in the National Anthem. We like to be together as a whole like our entire country but we always like being the indviduals that we are. Saying that I think our government has some totalitarian characteristics but not enough for a hard military government. Another big subject is we the people get to make choices for our government, in North Korea the people are ruled in every way and that would go well if someone tried to do that to the United States now.
ReplyDeleteMorgan Gabriel
ReplyDeletePSCI 100.05
Yes, I think that some of the features associated with totalitarian governments resemble aspects of life in our political system. Discipline is definitely a good example. People in our political system do obey our authoritative figures, but there are also the people who do not. There are plenty of people in the US who would go out of their way for the better of our country, such as the people who go into the army, navy etc. On the other hand, there are people who could careless about what our country is going to or what the government has to say.
As we were talking about in class today, I agree with the fact that the US is puritan for the most part, and we are very patriotic. People in the US love their country and they also show it by showing flags and other ways.
Our government in the United States is similar to the totalitarian system in a few ways. We are very patriotic like the people in these systems. Whenever the country is in a crisis such as 911 or other tragic events we tend to stand together as a whole. Every year on September 11 we will have a moment of silence to honor the play killed that day. That shows strong patriotism throughout the country. After this tragic event the government became very vigilant as we declared war on Iraq. I see many characteristics that could group as in somewhat as a type of totalitarian system.
ReplyDeleteOur government in the United States is similar to the totalitarian system in a few ways. We are very patriotic like the people in these systems. Whenever the country is in a crisis such as 911 or other tragic events we tend to stand together as a whole. Every year on September 11 we will have a moment of silence to honor the play killed that day. That shows strong patriotism throughout the country. After this tragic event the government became very vigilant as we declared war on Iraq. I see many characteristics that could group as in somewhat as a type of totalitarian system.
ReplyDeleteWayne Fleming
I think that some aspects of totalitarian society do identify with our political system in the United States and probably other governments around the world too. Patriotism is a big part of our country. As Americans, we have rights and liberties which other country’s citizens do not. The love for our country is celebrated on a daily basis. American flags attached to homes, saying the pledge at school, and singing the national anthem before events are all efforts of patriotism. There are so many holidays recognizing our American history like Independence Day, Presidents Day, Memorial Day, Veterans Day, etc. Along with patriotism, we are “hate filled” of our country’s enemies. Certain figureheads such as Osama Bin Laden have been matched as an enemy of our country after the 9-11 events. The enemies evoke a sense of patriotism in our country with more pride and support. We also can recognize with the “party minded” aspect of totalitarianism. We, as citizens, are instruments to political parties in our country because we vote. Elections help authorities to decide and put into action what we as “the people” are in favor of by majority rule. The “vigilant” aspect also applies to our society. “Big Brother” is in a sense, ‘the enemy’ which is always watching. The government may not always be watching us as closely as totalitarian societies, but there is always a sense of government presence and awareness every day, everywhere. Lastly, we are disciplined by our government. We obey authorities to avoid punishments. Social order created by governmental authorities is “for the betterment of the collective.” Things like obeying traffic laws to steer clear of the police and paying taxes to avoid conviction by the IRS are parts of social order which have penalties if not obeyed. I never realized the ways in which our society is like totalitarian government. However, I believe the difference is the extent which the government enforces the ‘rules.’
ReplyDeleteCayce Martin PSCI 100.04
In some ways our government is similar to that of a totalitarian government. Two specific ways are patriotic and hate filled. Most of the citizens of the United States are proud Americans and wave the flag, perform the appropriate gestures while the anthem is being sung or the pledge is being said. These are acts of patriotism. In relation to patriotism, hate filled is also a trait of our government. Almost all adults and many children in the United States could tell you who the enemy is; they would say Osama Bin Laden. People recognize Bin Laden as the enemy mainly because of the terrorist attack in September 2001. Ironically this attack enforced both patriotism and hate.
ReplyDeleteEmmi Shambeda
PSCI 100.05
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteI believe that the American government and a Totalatarian system are completly opposite in almost all things. Espcecially colletivist, modesty, and party minded. For collectivist, everyone in America is supposed to have their own goals and freedoms, it is a citizens rights. Not many people in America are willing to self sacrifice or give a lot of things up for the government which makes us not modest and giving. And instead of believing we are part of the political parties, I think many ciizens believe the party should be part of them and do what they want.
ReplyDeleteNow what is somewhat similiar is the United States ability to be patriotic and vigilant. But in the United states we are vigilant against outside forces and evils, not each other. In a totalatarian system, people are vigilant amongst eachother and try to find traitors of the party. And I believe the patriotism just comes from pride and the fact that citizens are proud to be part of the so called strongest nation in the world. Not because they are told to like in a totalatarian system. This is why I believe the US way of life and the totalitarian systems are completly opposite.
Sam Beatty
Poli Sci 100.04
We are similar and different both at the same times. There is an important stress in both governments to be an active political and economically contributing citizens. Also, patriotism is something that our country prides itself on greatly. After Sept. 11th many Americans came together in our time of need. However, fear of our enemy has risen out of this and we are similar to the totalitarian system in this way. However, our love and support for our political activist our not always agreeing. Most likely because our own self interest are not being meet. In a totalitarian system the people support practically worship their leader. When walking into a typical American house , the presidents picture is not displayed as it would be in all houses of a totalitarian community. For this I am glad that we are different from the totalitarian form of government but yet we are similar in many ways.
ReplyDeleteI can agree with most of the posts here in that there are some similarities between our US regime and that of a totalitarian government. However, to insinuate that the two governing states are at the same level of the 8 characteristics mentioned would be very extreme. As Americans, we like to think of ourselves as a very patriotic peoples. While totalitarian regimes feel this way as well, the people living under the government do not have a choice as to whether or not they would prefer to feel that way. If you choose not to express an extreme sense of patriotism in the United States you may be looked down upon or asked to show some "respect" towards our country. In a totalitarian regime if the citizens do not show patriotism they have the option of either being killed or "vaporized" as was mentioned in "1984."
ReplyDeleteThe US is also in a sense more pure than most European countries. We tend to see sex as a bad thing that should be saved for marriage where most European countries integrate sex into their societies without question. However, sex before marriage and behind closed doors is very possible in the United States and is not punishable by law like it is in a totalitarian regime. The same goes for remaining disciplined and vigilant. While those feelings aren't as extreme in the US, they do exist (by choice). That, in my opinion is the biggest difference between most forms of government and the totalitarian form of government. Civilians tend to feel impulses such as patriotism, vigilance, puritanism, hate, and activism to some extent under all major forms of government. The distinct difference is that they choose to feel that way. Unfortunately, in a totalitarian regime, these feelings are anything but choices.
I agree with Chris Schildts comment. our country is extremely patriotic, there are plenty of American flags hanging at peoples homes, at local schools, or coorperations. Wherever you go you will find an American flag. At every major sporting event the National Anthem is played. But like Chris said, its not too the point where we are worshiping our politcal figures and having a shrine of there pictures in our homes.Yes some people may and may feel that way. However, most Americans are not too the point where they are not learning their values from their politcal figures. It is mostly the religious figures where they are seeking answers for their values and beliefs.
ReplyDeletekasey mercier 100.03
ReplyDeleteI do agree with that some of the points of a totalitarian gov't has,America also has.One strong point is our strong love of our country.We have been in a war since 2001,and I think our patroitism has been bigger than ever.Even if some of our fellow citizens may not believe in our President for example,at the end of the day they still support our love for our country. Another strong point we have in common is the fact that we have a enemy of the state. Who is, none other than Bin Laden. I can bet money that people from the age of 5 to 95 years old know who excatly Bin Laden is and that we as America must hate him. But just because we some points in common with a totalitarian gov't doesn't mean that we are a totalitarian system.I belive we are free as ever.
ReplyDeleteCourtney Pepperling
PSCI 100.04
I think that is some ways we do follow the totalitarian rule, but in a lot of ways we don’t. One way is that we are very patriotic and another is hate filled. We are patriotic because look how many people fly the flag, stand when the nation anthem is sung, and stand when the pledge is said. Like on September 11 everyone came together that day to help in one way or another. Also we are hate filled by the way we hate our enemy such as Osama Bin Laden.
ReplyDeleteAshley Mellott
PSCI 100.03
I don't think that we are completely opposite from the totalitarian government although some things clearly differentiate us. Every one is an "instrument of the political party." If you don't belong to a democrat or republican party, don't you still chose who you want to be elected? Even if you didn't vote, don't you still criticize who is in power in one way or another? For patriotic. There are many American's that are very patriotic and some that are not. That's as simple as it gets. Collectivist. For this, the public goals aren't necessarily more important to individuals than their own goals, but in a totalitarian system and in our society, I think they are close. We look at public problems and goals and are involved. Not everyone is going to help you with your own aspirations. So in a sense, we have that in common. As a country, there is a well known enemy and there is the same hatred to this one person just like totalitarians. This does not bring out patriotism though. I think the activism would be something new and not really practiced. As for being disciplined, if we as a country were this, we wouldn't need jails and such strict laws. Today, I don't believe that people are as modest as they should and could be.
ReplyDelete100.4
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteNone of these really hit me as being part of the American government as a whole. For every aspect I quickly found a counter example. However, if I look at in terms of political parties the counter examples are less forthcoming.
ReplyDeleteI believe the Tea Party would be the best example; not because they are fun to pick on, but because they rely so heavily on the loyalty of their members. I know many of them see Obama as an enemy of the state, even though he is the Head of State. They are also the most party minded and patriotic of the current political parties. Their conservative values also stress self-discipline and modesty. Systems are made to work and the totalitarian system does work (just because it works does not mean it's good). So is it surprising that the tea party has taken such a strong footing in America’s political system?
An aspect that really jumps out at me as being part of the everyday American way of life is the "vigilance" aspect of totalitarianism. It is obvious the Americans are encouraged to be ever vigilant for "terrorist". There is most definitely a very strong hate towards that people, which is another aspect of totalitarianism. Again, if I break this down into parties we could look at hatred that way. After the Tulsa Shooting fingers were pointed to the right, namely Sarah Palin. And, of course, after she denounced that the shootings had any political motivation she quickly pointed the finger back to the left saying if it weren’t for their flimsy morals "they would have no morals at all." It’s disturbing how much hatred and demonizing goes on in the political system. When I see it I can usually pick out the demonizing out of the normal political banter, but I’m fearful that others can't. If someone believed whole-heartedly in everything a cretin party said that person would be a danger to the other half of society.
Theres a stron correlation of both types among our country. It all depends on who you look at. About wether or not they grew in a patriotic environment or were isolated from any of the eight traits. Someone who grew up with a close family member who is in the military might feel strong patriotism, be very vigilant, and be very disciplined. Especially compared to someone who grew up without a family member in the military, but they might have grown up around the media. So that persons views would be based around that. It just depends on the individual and how, where, and when they grew up.
ReplyDeleteMatthew Kimberlin
PSCI 100.05
I think between our government and a totalitarian government, four of the eight stand out. we are definitely patriotic. As we said in class, we are one of the most patriotic countries in the world. we are proud to show our flag and say we are American. I also think we are hate filled because on September 11th, we as a country grew to hate the enemy (the terrorists) and went to war with these people. For the most part, we are disciplined. We obey the laws and if not we may go to jail. We have respect for authority in our everyday lives. Finally, we are modest and puritan. Although sometimes we may not think we are, compared to other countries we are very modest with the ways we act in public.
ReplyDeleteKassi Gardner 100.05
I believe that Americans fully share being patriotic and being modest with a totalitarian population. As it was pointed out in class today, our country is often called the "flag country." Every where anyone goes in America there is an American flag. In general Americans are very patriotic but our patriotism is unbeliveably obvious after national crisises, such as the September 11th terrorist attacks. On the note of our country's population being modest, Dr. Stump gave an extremely good example today. In America we hide engaging in extreme pleasures, whereas in other countries, such as Amsterdam, people freely buy prosititues and smoke weed. Another area that Americans might have in common with the population of a totalitarian regime is the aspect of loving work and politics. This is much of a lesser scale than being patriotic or modest. As a whole, our country is very work driven, in that many people grow up being expected to go to college and get a job. Most often Americans are also encouraged to choose an occupation inwhich they will enjoy and be happy with, which would make people love work. On the scale of loving politics: our country seems to be driven by only politics at some times. Citizens get so caught up with politics from a local town election to so big as the presidential election. For some Americans, politics is what they live for. These are the similaries that I see between the American population and that of a totalitarian but of course this is all on less of an extreme scale.
ReplyDeleteStephanie Trupo 100.03
I see a few similar characteristics between our government and a totalitarian society, including: lots of patriotism and hate filled people towards the enemies, as well as a little of collectivism and vigilant actions. I see collectivism because we are told we are free to do as we wish, but if these actions hint towards unlawfulness or any rebellion towards the nation we are reprimanded. As vigilantes we cannot go around killing anyone we please; yet, as law abiding citizens we all know the image of “terrorists” and it is our American duty to report any suspicious behavior. However, this system is not as strict about this to the point where no one is able to have open, intimate relationships. American citizens for the most part are very individualistic, but yet a large majority of us are simply, to quote Professor Stump: “cogs in the wheel,” while trying to reach the American dream and serving our country, which we have heard about throughout our U.S upbringing. I agree that these characteristics can be found within a hierarchal society, which are needed in aiding the country to run smoothly, but the degree in which they are managed defies the lines of different forms of government.
ReplyDeleteLaura Bobbitt 100.03
America appears to be far removed from any type of totalitarian government, but how can we be sure things are as they appear. One student pointed out that most Americans ascribe to a party, either democrat or republican. And as we all know, the differences between the two can be huge and a source of conflict. In fact some party members view the other party much like a enemy. I am in agreement with the others that Americans are patriotic as displayed by our own customs and emblems. I also think America shares the characteristic of puritanism. By observing our societies skimpy wardrobes and crude or lewd television shows one might not think we are prude or concerned with modesty. But many Americans get up in arms about sex education being taught to children in schools or other public forums and even within homes it seems to be a conversation most don't want to have. For as much as America likes to sell sexuality you rarely see any commercials advertising condoms like they do in Europe. I think this reflects prude attitudes or at least underlying shame about sexuality. I think we also share in vigilance. People are always looking over their shoulder for the next thug or scam artist, and since 9-11 all people appearing middle eastern.There seems to be a collective generalized fear that encourages hate within individuals. While the government may not control our every move and thought I do think our government parallels totalitarianism in many ways. Perhaps even at this moment we are under surveillance...who would know, unless one of us became a large enough threat and were "vaporized".
ReplyDeleteChristina Page 100.04
I believe that America follows a few of the above qualities listed. When I read over them, vigilant, patriotic, and hate-filled were the three that stuck out to me the most. Like mentioned by previous comments, September 11th sparked a new level of patriotism among Americans and with patriotism also came a vigilant and hate-filled society. In general, many view the Middle East and Muslims as our enemies due to the terrorist attacks. When we go out in public and see someone of Eastern descent, we automatically become more cautious and tend to keep our eye on the activities of the individuals. However, Muslims aren’t the only ones subjected to hate, individuals that appear to be from Mexico or other Central and South American countries are automatically labeled as illegal immigrants and are subjected to hate. Therefore, I see it as appropriate to relate America to these three features.
ReplyDeleteJenna Peck
PSCI 100.04
A few similarities exist such as our patriotism and somewhat disacplined. Although I believe that we are more different than the same. We have no love for a party, even though some have love for a political party. Most of us are not modest either. Many of Americans whether they like it or not, are very upfront and ,brutal. We as a society are more geared towards promoting ourselves and not thinking twice about another indivual comes as second nature to us.
ReplyDeleteDerek Buckley PSCI 100.03
I don't think there are any similarities other than patriotism. We as Americans have an extreme love for our country and cling to our historical backgrounds and myths just like in a totalitarian system. The biggest difference is our individualism vs their collectiveness. Our goals as individual outweigh those of the nation most of the time. Under attack or extreme pressure we tend to unify as a collective group but overall we are individualistic. Two parties is not much more than one but it makes a huge difference in the political arrangement as there are challenges and different views on specific topics. In totalitarian government there is one party and one view on how to do things. Nobody opposes the view for fear of death or they just don't know any better. Totalitarian governments can't be compared to our capitalists democracy/republic.
ReplyDeleteLevi McDonald PSCI 100.03
I can see our countries government having similar characteristics as a Totalitarian government. Americans are very party minded. You either are democratic or republican. Each are very different and argue about views that each think are more important than the other. Americans are very patriotic, you see the American flag flying almost everywhere you go. At any and all sports events the star spangled banner is sung or played. Americans in our politcal system are very vigilant. As we talked in class we dont like terrorist. Expecially Muslims because they could be in America trying to blow us up. The matter of the fact is most Americans havent even known or really got to know a Muslim. So how would you know that would be their intentions. Hate filled is another big comparison we hate poeple in Iraq, and Afghanistan. They are the ones that are killing our troops, and blowing things up. These are the things I have heard poeple say. These are just some few comparisons, that I believe our politcal system has between a Totalitarian government. Yes there are some major differences in both governments but there is indeed similarities that we in our politcal system share as well.
ReplyDeleteJoshua Labuhn PSCI 100.03
Ian Hickman 100.05
ReplyDeleteAlthough totalitarian and democratic governments are very different; they do share some similarities, which I will point out using the U.S. as an example. There are times where our country is very patriotic. The only difference I believe is that in a totalitarian system, the patriotism is continuous and in our country patriotism is more of a ‘Rally around the flag” effect, meaning that it takes something to happen which brings about serious impact to our country (whether it be negative, such as 9/11, or something positive like elections). We would deny the fact that we are ‘collectivist’ however; it is my opinion that our party leaders and political figures seek what is in the best interest of themselves and their fellow elitists, while downplaying issues relating to the best interest of the general population. They create laws and run a regime that benefits them more than us. Our country is certainly hate filled, and actually overly hate filled. I say overly hate filled because people don’t even know who or why they hate, but if one mentions, Iraq, Afghanistan, the middle east, or they see someone who may look of this descent, typically the hate-switch goes off and they assume they shouldn’t like these people because of the terrorist acts of a few people from their race/ethnicity. Not every middle easterner is a terrorist, but the mass media in America paints a picture that negatively resembles much of the Middle East (or at least for those who don’t follow the news enough to know the real issues and who is doing what). We are not however disciplined. Why? Because we are ‘ the land of the free’, or so they say. There are a few similarities as I have pointed out, but the complete control over public/private behavior, and individual ideology demonstrated by a totalitarian system is what sets them apart from our society.
In some ways I do believe that the eight features associated with totalitarian governments do resemble aspects of life in our own political system. In some form or another they are all evident in our own governing system. Although one may be named totalitarian and the other may be capitalist, these features are apparent under different systems, such as patriotic which people are from the time the United States was born. People have are patriotic by participating in the pledge of allegiance, putting up the United States flags, participating in event and such. Also there is evidence of collectivism when 9/11 happened people came together which also leads to hate filled, like how the media showed Osama bin Laden has the enemy of the state. People be under different governing systems but still in a subtle or not so subtle manner people to a degree behave or have the same quatlies.
ReplyDeleteSofia Khan
PSCI 100.05
Our government does have some similarities to these eight but they are not the same ideas. Party minded is in our government in a sense of bettering our country but not in a sense of worship or being under control. The U.S. is very patriotic in our news, shows, movies, and even personal lives. A lot of people are devoted to the ideal of being a strong country before being individuals. We are not a collectivist nation. Vigilance is enacted in times of war like saying jabs, Charlie, reds, or terrorists when we refer to an enemy. We aren’t so much hate filled unless we are in a war. We defiantly aren’t the love work and political activism kind of people we tend to do our own thing and tend our own affairs. We have discipline but in comparison we are nothing like a totalitarian sense of discipline. The U.S. has modesty but not on the same scale as the total systems. We like to show and do things on the edge that they wouldn’t be allowed to do. Anthony Harley 100.05
ReplyDeleteOur political system is both similar and completely different from a totalitarian rule. While our nation is extremely patriotic and everyone is proud to be American, we lack collectivism. In most case an individual care less about public goals and more about private goals. The hate filled aspect really depends on the situation when 9/11 happened everyone had a strong sense of love for the country and the enemy was the object of hate. But that is during a crisis, most of the time everyone just hates the government. As for Party Minded it really changes with who you ask. Love work and political activism… not in this country. I would say over all our political system is not like totalitarian rule.
ReplyDeleteSusan Stout
PSCI 100.05
All eight features of totalitarian rule are present in our political system. Each one, however, is present in varying degrees.
ReplyDeleteMost Americans see themselves as party minded, although their loyalty is not toward one party. The two dominant political parties, Republican and Democratic, are the most prevalent choices. During election time, we see a great deal of party loyalty and many people construct their lives around their party choices, and would like nothing better than to see "their" party rule.
The U.S. population took patriotism to new levels, and sometimes extremes, after the 911 attacks.
Collectivism has varying degrees: on the national level there is the military, we show it in our local areas such as schools and churches, and then there are national organizations in which many people place a collective identity like pro-choice/right to life groups and spend time lobbing the government for legislation of their choice.
Vigilants and hate-filled attitudes are sometimes kept under wraps to preserve an individuals family or lifestyle, but they are present in big ways - the attitudes towards muslims, and they are present in smaller ways - racial tensions still exist in many areas of the southern states where some high schools still have segregated proms.
Work and political activism are present in everyone's lives and at every turn, Americans are encouraged to identify and work with a political party, or to work harder at their jobs to be successful. The degrees vary, but certainly, the attitudes are there.
Absolutely, we are disciplined enough to follow the justice system and even dress codes at work and school. Traffic and criminal laws are for the collective good, and rules attending public schools and vaccinations are also for the collective good.
The modest puritan attitudes are prevalent within the religious communities and spill over into the government with such things as teaching abstinence in the school system instead of taking the more realistic view of offering students the ability of making educated choices regarding sex.
All of these things I see in our society and government. Although we all think that we would never live under a totalitarian rule, it is surprising how many small changes can be made within a period of time and we wouldn't even realize it until we were completely ensconced in a new government, much the same way Hitler made changes in Germany prior to World War II. This is why it is important to understand things like separation of church and state, and the importance of exercising the choices given to us such as voting and becoming involved in the selection of our elected officials.
Dee Pierce
PSCI 100.03
To an extent our government is like a totalitarian government. yes we are aloud to make our own decisions but that is only to an extent. we are aloud to pick democrat or republican but if someone were to say "i am part of the Taliban" then we would most likely subdue them. the government is always trying to sway the was we look at foreign issues by not always giving us the true shake down of what happened. it is always they shot first, they provoked us. but also we cannot just tell an official that someone is a part of the opposing party and have them vaporized.
ReplyDeleteOur governemnt is not like a totalitarian governemnt. When people in our society have kids they have them for the sake of extending their family, not for hte sake of what the party wants. Our government has become very patriotic especially after Septemeber 11, 2001. The citizens of our government took much thought and consideration into what took place on that day and are proudly waving their flags now. Individuals of our society definatly have a lot more privacy thean of a totalitarian government but our goals of the collective are more important. I feel that over all there are some aspects of our governemnt that associate wiht a totalitarian government.
ReplyDeleteMegan Long
PSCI 100.03
I think we resemble all of the features that are listed, just not to the very extreme. I believe that because everyone is so structured to societies norms at such a young age that one cannot help but to follow the herd to fit in and be accepted. Rules and disciplines are taught for people to have the right behavior towards others, if they are not taught them then we deal with people who can not get along with others and that becomes a problem for everyone else who has to deal with it. We do obey our government in reaction to fear of punishment of fines and imprisonment but we also obey it for its security it gives us as well. We also have very loud voices in our country so if things are not as we like it we have ways of disapproving through our votes, letters and protests.
ReplyDeleteI also think it has to do with what kind of group or job you are in that mite require those qualities such as the military or government which require full obedience for expectance. I believe that most every American just like any other country is patriotic because we are proud to have the freedoms that we do have even if they are not perfect. Because we have so many freedoms and have sheltered ourselves from the outside world, we do have many people who dislike us, which keeps us on a constant state of security and peer policing. The problem is that people take it to the extreme like a witch hunt and in their ignorance blame the wrong people and group. But unlike in a totalitarian government we have many forms of access for information and we are able to make our own opinion on what we think and how we feel as well as to share them with others and I believe that’s what makes us very different.
Katie Clevenger 100.05
In my opinion, I think we are very similar to a totalitarian government. We are party-minded by choosing democrat or republican when we vote. Others decide to go undecided and not choose a party. We are very patriotic we have the American flag on shirts, windows, and in our front yards. We stand up when the national anthem comes on. We are somewhat collective by choosing the president or the governor. We are valiant when it comes to the war like in Iraq. We send men over and train them for combat. We can have hate for someone who invades our country or hate toward another person. We try to help the community whenever we can like Hurricane Katrina, everyone got together to send food and clean up the mess. We have discipline like the police if someone tries to rob a store or murder. We can be modest at times but then selfish at the same time. If we want something bad enough we will do anything to get it. In some way I never thought how we are similar to a totalitarian government.
ReplyDeleteKathryn Stevens
100.04
I agree with Kathryn above. We flaunt our Patriotism on shirts, bumper stickers, windows, and flying the flag. Standing up, putting our hands over our hearts and saying the pledge of allegiance or singing the National Anthem has become just become a routine that we were taught at a young age. We train our military to not only fight over seas but to help when there is a natural disaster. We have rules and people to enforce them. There are punishments if you don't follow the rules and rewards if you do. We take pride in what we have and sometimes can be very selfish. Citizens show respect for our military men and women. I guess in some ways we really are close to a totalitarian government. I do agree that we have more freedoms and advantages though..
ReplyDeleteBekah Knipe
100.04
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteI am sure that a good percentege of people living in our american democracy see themselves as and instrument of our political parties. Between all of the bills that get passed in congress that we dont approve of, but hey we elected them to vote for our best interest right? When it comes to patriotism, i think of two words "short lived". After 9-11 there was a TREMENDOUS sense of patriotism across the United States, although after bush spoke his "mission accomplished" speech which was the furthest thing from the truth, everybody gradually sarted back to the way they were before by watching dancing with the stars rather than the nightly news, or at least colbert to know whats going on with our government. One thing America has never been is collective. Since i have been alive at least, i have not seen any sign or anyting close to i that america is a nation of shared prosperity and caring induviduals. America is a country of greed. Plan and simple the strongest survive and the wealthey and succesfull live the dream life. There are shades of some of these traits that were pointed out in American society but it by no means renders our country totalitarian ruled or even shows and uprising of so. America is a free market country of its own and unless there is a collective gathering of pepole, and or labor unions all striking against our government, nothing is going to change.
ReplyDeleteDillon Berger psci 100.4
I do think that our political system resembles a totalitarian government. Not in all aspects of life do we resemble a totalitarian government, but for sure in the party minded and the patriotic features we do. In a way we are like the party minded by carrying out daily activities for the government. We use self policing and peer policing to help control society. We are the instruments under government to help maintain order. Without being party minded chaos would break loose. As for the patriotic feature, many Americans defend their country. We all celebrate our veterans and the things this country has achieved. We have many holidays such as veterans day, memorial day, and the fourth of July that shows patriotism. Our political system is like a totalitarian government in these ways.
ReplyDeletePamela Smoot PSCI 100.04
I believe that our government contains alot of the same features as that of a totalitarian system. For instance, we are overtly patriotic. And it always seems like we are supposed to be divided over something and hating a certain group of people, like the Islamic population. Not to mention the patriot act, a clear violation of privacy. As well as our imperialist mentality.
ReplyDeleteRoss Tamaccio 100.03
By looking at the characterisitics for the Totalitarian government, it would seem like we also have some of them. Yet I believe the similarities are on two different ends of the spectrum. For one, we know the difference between this government and others. Also, the people in our country have a choice in who runs the government, hence why we vote. A Totalitarian run society does not know much about the outside world and nor do they know better. Therefore I conclude that America is nothing like that type of government.
ReplyDeleteHeather Reynolds
PSCI 100.04
I think we are similar in some ways. I do not think that all of those characteristics are alike. For example one characteristic that is similar is that we are patriotic, and take a lot of pride in our country and in our state. Another one that is similar is love work and political activism. I think that there are a lot of people in this country (not enough though) that are active in the government, also there are a number of people who have to love work, maybe they dont truly love it but they make it a priority in order to support for their family. Other than that i think that we are a lot different from totalitarian system. We have a lot more rights and although the government is involved with a lot and regulates a lot of things we still have our own freedom to do as we please.
ReplyDeleteChristina Ferrara
PSC 100.03
I do believe that the American government is very similar to the characteristics described above of a totalitarian government. We do follow the rules that the government has implemented upon us. We do love our country; like for instance, we might be the only country that has as many flags up as a country can possible have. Everywhere you go there is a flag, or some sort of devote of love for America. We are so proud (some people might agree) of defending our country in Iraq (our enemy), which once again is one of the characteristics of a totalitarian country. I will agree with some of the comments about being collectivist, but I do believe we are in some way vigilant; we are always looking for the enemy. As seen or heard in the news, whenever you see someone suspicious you have to report it to the nearest police officer, for example, like riding the metro in DC, there is even an announcement about this. Even more after all that has happened to the US in recent years, people are more aware of this.
ReplyDeleteJorge Alvarez
PSCI 100.03
I feel like we do show some of these features associated with totalitarian government in our political system. The one that stands out to me the most would be patriotism. Our country takes pride in what our soldiers are doing for our country. We've had alot happen to us since 2001, and we are still standing strong til this day due to the patriotism in America.
ReplyDeleteI feel like we are hate filled towards some countries due to World War 1 and 2, the Vietnam War, and the issue that happened in 2001. Many other countries are hate filled towards one another. Every country has an enemy, wether it be from the past or present.
In our country we are disciplined, but it's not as extreme as other countries. Our law enforcement is strict to a certain extent, but I feel like the way we are disciplined is handled pretty well.
Shayna Landis. Section 100.03
Some of the eight features are similar with our political system today, like patriotism and vigilant. Patriotism is really big in the United States of America and everywhere else in the world. Everyone shows pride for their country by putting flags on their doorsteps, by saying the pledge of allegiance, and among other things. The way we are also vigilant would be because of our life experiences. With a few examples like, Pearl Harbor and the twin towers. After those awful experiences we have been aware or our surroundings and we see people as dangerous. That is why the government and the people are on the lookout for suspiciousness basically anywhere because we do not want another awful experience to happen again.
ReplyDeleteAlaina Meserole PSCI 100.05
I believe that most of these are present in our own system of government. The most prominent being patriotism. In a totalitarian system people are all for the government they wear symbols of their government and post images around their home life and work areas. In our system of government we also have patriotism, symbols and such that we post around to show our support of a bigger idea. In the US we also have vigilence and hate, hard to think that we are that much like the totalitarian system, but we are taught to hate people from a young age that are enemy's of the state and we are taught vigilence to see things that are not ordinary. To sum this up, there are many things that our system of government has in common w/ a totalitarian system. PSCI 100.03
ReplyDeleteI feel that the some of the eight listed rules are kind of similar in a way that we are also very patriotic. WE like to honor our country by decals of the american flag on our cars to hanging them in our front yeards. Another similar trait number 7: Disciplined -- people easily obey figures of authority and curb their own private desires for the betterment of the collective. When driving around and spot a figure of authority your immediate reaction is too step on the brake. These traits fall very close to totalitarianism.
ReplyDeleteAshley Eckenrode 100.05
I think we are similar in some ways, such as patriotic. We are proud to be American but the negative parts between the two are that we do not have a major love for our political leadership because not everyone votes for the same leaders and representatives. I would have to call these an even split. We are opposite in most of these totally because in my opinion we do not view our political party as the most important aspect of our day. We don't always agree with what the politicians say or try to pursuade us to agree with, or get us to do. My privacy is important to me, my friends, and my loved ones, I would not share it with others. I feel this allows people to be sneaky in order to get around the totalitarian governments eyes and ears. However we do listen to authority that holds a consequence if we disobey, which is another similarity. Having so many differences between our government and a totalitarian ruler, I would completely fail and be punished if our nation lived within a totalitarian reign.
ReplyDeleteErik Peat PSCI 100.03
I believe that mostly we as americans are patriotic. I mean one day a year we celebrate america just being here by wearing red white and blue and doing all of the patriotic things. Many fight for our country because they love the country they live in and many americans stand togther and support the pepole that do this for us. Although we are not all of the examples stated having some of these qualities makes us the country that we are.
ReplyDeleteHanna Simane 100.05
There are some similarities in our government when it comes to being vigilant and patriotic. I feel theses two aspects were increased after 9/11. Flags were seen everyone and security greatly increased, especially at airports. There was a feeling of nervousness and suspecion after the attacks, but also great pride for our country. People began volunteering anywhere they could and became more interested in the political leaders of that time. Everyone joined together. However, these two aspects hardly point to totalitarianism. I feel that most countries would act this way if attacked. As far as comparison goes, thats pretty much the only things in common.
ReplyDeleteMiranda Beahm
PSCI 100.05
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteBen Goldman
ReplyDeletePSCI 100.03
So, after looking at the eight features of a totalitarian government, one can concur that our governmental system shares some of the same aspects. The main point that both governments have in common is the patriotism. In the United States most people are proud to be Americans at least that seems to be the general consensus. Also, the feature of vigilance is active in our system. We are always ready for the enemy, who knows if that is a good aspect. For the thought of protection it is phenomenal to know we have such an immense military that is always ready at the sound of a command. As for the comment before mine, everything they stated is very true. After 9/11 our patriotism became so much stronger. Everyone became unified and tried to help in any way possible. This is how our Country should always act. So, our system of government differs from a totalitarian government, but there are some similarities.
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteI agree with Colin. Most of the features are in our own system. I also agree that from a young age we are brought up with hate. Just like when we are told not to talk to strangers at a young age. Humans build a mental image of the way people look and what type of people to avoid. Just like how almost everyone has an idea of what a "terrorist" may look like even if that is not truly the case. The totalitarian government provides their enemies with a better reputation for their people so those people will put their trust in and support that government.
ReplyDeleteChristopher White PSCI 100.03
I believe the difference between a totalitarian government and ours is moderation. In my opinion, the majority of Americans fit into about 3 of these categories (patriotic, vigilant and hate filled) but we are not extremists about them. Many of us love America, and speaking for myself I would not want to live anywhere else. Vigilant, because the news of terrorism is played all around us so typically everyone is at least subconsciously curious about people that look “different”. For example if you’re at an airport and you see Muslim people dressed in their traditional attire, you naturally feel a little sketchy about them. Finally, hatred towards the enemy. For example after the attacks on Pearl Harbor and after 911 Americans were ready to fight and demonized the enemy to give even more of an incentive to retaliate.
ReplyDeleteMatt Santmier PSCI 100.03
Our government has a mixture of the classifications of a totalitarian style government. Their discipline levels are a little extreme just like a totalitarian government. Citizens of the US are very patriotic. Also, all Americans are very hate filled. Most show hate filled through prejudiced towards others.
ReplyDeleteLacie Sirk PSCI 100.05
I agree with Christina at the beginning of the post about being patriotic. Americans are very patriotic to wearing flag pins on jackets to songs that address the USA. On the other hand, I do not think our government fits any of the other totalitarian styles. Americans are selfish and self centered. It is a dog eat dog world out there, and Americans are taught to fight to survive.
ReplyDeleteAmy Sultner PSCI 100.03
We have a couple things that resemble a totalitarian government. Our government shows both patriotism and discipline. After 9/11 there was a large increase in patriotism through the U.S. Citizens also usually do what people of authority say to do and fallow the laws. In some aspects we are like totalitarian governments but in some ways we differ.
ReplyDeleteKristin Knotts 100.05
I believe there are a few similarities between our government and totalitarianism. Our patriotism for our country is one of the similarities that we have. We as Americans show our love for our country in various ways.I also think being hate filled is a similarity with our govenment and totalitarian because when 9/11 happened pretty much everyone in America was infuriated with Bin Laden, even myself as a child at the time showed hatred towards him and his people. Other than these two points I don't see too much else in common with our government and totalitarianism.
ReplyDeleteSecily Butts
PSCI 100.02
Our government and that of a totalitarian government have a few things in common. After looking at the the statements about totalitarian rule, I can say that we do share many of those traits. We may not be as extreme in some of them but we are alike in a lot of them. We show our patriotism even more when we are based with hardships. I also believe we are on the vigilant side. We naturally worry about our own safety and no matter how hard people try when we are around certain people we can become uneasy. Another one that i believe we fall into is the party minded. We constantly consider ourselves involved in one party or another and express our views according to the beliefs of that party.
ReplyDeleteAnissa Myers 100:04
I believe that there are a few similarities between our government and a totalitarianism. We are very patriotic and love to show affection to our country. But we are not the same because we are very negative and self centered at times.
ReplyDeleteCourtney Owens
PSCI 100.03
I think in some ways we do resemble a totalitarian government, but in most we do not. When analyzing government by the list of totalitarian qualities, Americans probably hold 3 of 8. We have patriotism, hate(of others that have harmed our country) and are, for the most part, disciplined. The list is fairly general, but we do hold some of the qualities of a totalitarian government. Our society has a different structure to it, but still is alike in a few ways.
ReplyDeleteKindra Bittle PSCI 100.03
I agree with Anissa with the fact that America shares some totalitarian traits. We have had patriotism installed in us since our younger years. We always had to say the pledge and place our hand over our hearts. Even though they said "we didn’t have to", it was pretty much you do it or look stupid type of thing. Also, I feel that we Americans are very disciplined. Maybe not so much as the people living in a totalitarian system but we respect our authority figures. We also have a lot of party minded in our country. For the most part, we have two major parties that are always getting in political debates amongst one another. The place where we DIFFER from a totalitarian system is the fact that we really do not "hate" anyone. We are very vigilant towards others countries however, always worried about what they might be up to but in my eyes, we do not "hate" anyone per say.
ReplyDeleteBrittney Butler 100.03
There are some similar ways between our U.S government and the totalitarianism but I think a lot of the features are for good. For example, one would be hate filled. The government informs us of who the "bad guys" are in society and want us to be warned of them and the natural reaction would be to dislike a terrorist. Another would be patriotism. A lot of people wave their flag in their yard and show a lot of support, but then again nobody is ever really content with the United States.
ReplyDeleteMorgan Himmighoefer
PSCI 100.05
There are a couple similarities between our government and a totalitarian government but then again there are also similarities between a democracy and a socialist government. Our government is in fact very patriotic in the sense that we spend the majority of our budget on security and our defense system but we are no where near the physiological characteristics of a totalitarian government. The people of a totalitarian government are way more brain washed than us and don't have as much individualism. Also the main difference is, although we do have two primary parties we have more than one electoral party and choices for society. I would never want to live in a totalitarian government.
ReplyDeleteCasie mand
PSCI 100.03